what could it be?

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by bookie29, Jun 22, 2005.

  1. bookie29

    bookie29 Guest

    ihave a 300m chrylser and i've changed the battery in it 3 times in
    6months. some say its my alarm system that is draining the battery but
    some people say its my alternator. my battery is not even 6 months yet and
    my car wont start. when i try to get a "jump off" it still wont crank.
    please help what could it be.
     
    bookie29, Jun 22, 2005
    #1
  2. bookie29

    Bill Putney Guest

    Since you say it stilll won't crank when jumped, it would seem that it
    would have to be:
    (1) Bad starter,
    (2) A loose connection - the positive jump post connection (on top of
    the passenger side of the engine visible when you open the hood) would
    be a prime candidate, or
    (3) a bad ignition switch.

    Regarding (2), above, with the exception of the direct conection between
    battery and alternator, *all* electrical power goes thru the positive
    jump node. One cable from your battery, one cable to the starter, and a
    third cable to everything else. It could be that one or both nuts on
    the pos. jump post stud are loose and the terminal for the cable to the
    starter is making poor contact - which can be intermittent and wouild
    also grow steadily worse from heat (due to high resistance connection).
    Item (2) does happen on LH cars - it happened on mine, and I have
    correctrly pointed many Lh car owners on Chrysler forums to that as a
    cause of a problem similar to yours (though that is not the only
    possible cause as pointed out).

    If you don't know how to use a multimeter/voltmeter to properly diagnose
    such problems, then take it to a competent mechanic who can. It is
    clear to me that you haven't found that person yet with the guesswork
    that has gone on with this to date. For example, a bad alternator or an
    alarm system draining the system would not make a car fail to crank with
    a jump!

    I get the impression that the problem is fairly constant (not too
    intermittent). That being the case, it should not take an honest,
    competent mechanic long to find the root cause of the problem and
    correct it. For example - a bad alternator could be ruled in or out in
    seconds with a voltmeter in the hands of someone minimally competent.

    Bill Putney
    (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my
    adddress with the letter 'x')
     
    Bill Putney, Jun 22, 2005
    #2
  3. bookie29

    Bob Shuman Guest

    If it clicks, but won't crank, it is likely the starter solenoid contacts
    that are shot.

    Bob
     
    Bob Shuman, Jun 22, 2005
    #3
  4. bookie29

    Art Guest

    After the battery is removed from the car, have you checked to see if it is
    discharged? If it is not discharged then it has nothing to do with the
    battery or charging system.
     
    Art, Jun 22, 2005
    #4
  5. I would blame the tech who didn't catch the real problem after changing the
    battery the first time.
     
    Alex Rodriguez, Jun 22, 2005
    #5
  6. That's right, if you AIN"T got what it takes to be helpful, just criticize
    and put people down.
    Blaming the tech does not fix the problem nor does it answer his question.
    Might I suggest to you Alex a few new, more appropriate newsgroup for you to
    spread your wealth of knowledge upon.
    alt.asshole-factory
    alt.ima.loser.and.you.can.be.too
    alt.ignorant.fucks
    lastly for those of you considering not wearing your seatbelt alt.
    society.civil-disob

    I am sure everyone here will miss your helpful suggestions.


     
    Father of the Year, Jun 22, 2005
    #6
  7. bookie29

    bookie29 Guest

    thanks for all the replys ive gotten back i will take all advice in
    consideration. keep them coming.
     
    bookie29, Jun 22, 2005
    #7
  8. bookie29

    David Guest

    This, from a helpful deadbeat dad. Your comments are just as bad! Did you
    help him with his question?
    Nope! So anyway, how's it feel not being able to raise the kids because your
    a moron? Good thing you are paying your way though!
     
    David, Jun 23, 2005
    #8
  9. 1. Not a deadbeat, who said I was Nostradamous?
    2. If you have kids, it can happen to you. I don't wish it upon you or
    anyone especially your kids? But the laws promote your wife dumpin your ass
    and taking the kids and then you can pay her while you have the kids....go
    figure.
    3. I came here with a question for the experts. Tim and only Tim helped me
    out and the rest of you showed and continue to demonstrate what you are.
    4. My previous life was stolen from me by the corrupt family laws and an
    even more corrupt ex wife.....Not because I was or am an asshole but because
    she found someone who made more money than me!!!!

    I am an asshole because I don't want to wear my seatbelt. Yall
    happy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
     
    Father of the Year, Jun 23, 2005
    #9
  10. Question: ihave a 300m chrylser and i've changed the battery in it 3 times
    in
    6months. some say its my alarm system that is draining the battery but
    some people say its my alternator. my battery is not even 6 months yet and
    my car wont start. when i try to get a "jump off" it still wont crank.
    please help what could it be.

    Answer: I would blame the tech who didn't catch the real problem after
    changing the
    battery the first time.
    --------------
    Alex



    Yep, I guess I was out of line. That is a real good answer Alex. NAH I
    wasn't out of line.
     
    Father of the Year, Jun 23, 2005
    #10
  11. I forgot to mention that I am not here on this board to help people fix
    their cars, I am here to get help. My expertise is in other areas. Unlike
    you Dave....I found this one quite funny after
    you said, Did you help him with his question?
    Nope! So anyway, how's it feel not being able to raise the kids because
    your a moron? Good thing you are paying your way though! I looked at some
    of you advice:
    Can anyone shed some light on the universal coolant?
    Thanks, Ted

    Yes, It is called Water. You mix it with Prestone antifreeze! They must have
    been out of it at the time.

    Yep you are a genius and I am sure the kids you had with your wife are
    really yours.
     
    Father of the Year, Jun 23, 2005
    #11
  12. bookie29

    Joe Guest

    One thing's for sure. You won't get it fixed by listening to what people
    say. Talk is cheap.

    First step is to buy a volt ohm meter. You might want to buy a battery
    charger too, unless you have an easy way to get these batteries replaced
    free. Whatever's most convenient for you. Then let's talk about it.
     
    Joe, Jun 23, 2005
    #12
  13. bookie29

    KWS Guest

    It might help if you tell us a few things about your situation:

    How long did you have the car prior to this episode of changing batteries?

    When you first had the problem, why did you change the battery? Were you
    told by someone that it was either "dead" or it "wouldn't hold a charge". If
    so, can you describe what type of testing resulted in this diagnosis?

    When the battery was changed as a result of the first question; was it
    replaced with a brand new battery? I will refer to this replacement battery
    as the "first" battery.

    When the battery was changed the "second" time, did you have the person who
    sold you the "first" battery confirm it had failed? What did they tell you
    about the battery?

    Same questions regarding the "third" battery.

    How old is the Chrysler; how many miles does it have on it?

    Maybe with a little more information, someone will be able to help you.

    Regards,

    Ken
     
    KWS, Jun 23, 2005
    #13
  14. bookie29

    David Guest

    Maybe, maybe not. But I have mine!
     
    David, Jun 23, 2005
    #14
  15. bookie29

    bookie29 Guest

    my car was used when i bought it a year ago. the first time it happened it
    started about 4 days after i bought it. "they" said that the battery was
    dead so i bought another battery. then it happend again they said it was
    the starter so i bought a new starter. now its happening again. when it
    happened the second time i took it auto zone to check my battery and it
    was good. my car has about 110,000 miles on it right now bc of traveling
    back and forth from MS to NC. but i have a technician come to my house and
    he said its probably the battery or the alternator but not for sure till he
    get his "tools" to see the problem. so till he comes back with his tools he
    will let me know for sure. he works with electrical stuff on cars. i hope
    he can give me a definite answer.
     
    bookie29, Jun 23, 2005
    #15
  16. bookie29

    Bill Putney Guest

    Sounds like a good plan since all of our crystal balls are in the shop
    right now. 8^) (you didn't quite explain the *three* batteries, but
    that's OK)

    Bill Putney
    (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my
    adddress with the letter 'x')
     
    Bill Putney, Jun 23, 2005
    #16
  17. bookie29

    Art Guest

    Do you have another late model car with an embedded chip in they key?
    According to my Toyota Avalon owner's manual, those keys can interfere with
    each other and need to be kept away from the ignition when the car is
    started or the car won't start.
     
    Art, Jun 24, 2005
    #17
  18. bookie29

    KWS Guest

    So you replaced the battery that was originally in the car when you bought
    it with another battery. That "first" battery apparently is good; at least
    AutoZone seems to think so.

    When you brought the battery to AutoZone, was it dead (requiring a
    re-charge)?

    When the car refuses to start, do other things electrical continue to work.
    For instance, do the interior lights work, does the radio play, do the
    headlights work?

    If the battery is indeed alive (as evidenced by the folks at AutoZone and
    stuff working as I described above), I would vote for something in the
    primary starter circuit being bad. It's probably not the starter, since you
    replaced it. First place I would look would be the ignition switch or
    appropriate fuse. Next choices would be the neutral/park switch if it's an
    automatic and I would work my way from there. Your technician buddy with his
    trusty multimeter likely understands how to do this.

    All the best,

    Ken
     
    KWS, Jun 24, 2005
    #18
  19. bookie29

    BobbyG Guest

    First of all, you'll need a volt meter. Hook it up to positive & negative
    on Battery, without engine running, if the battery is fully charged it
    should read 12 to 13 volts. now start the engine and you should now have
    around 14 volts. If not alternator is N/G. If alternator checks out ok,
    then my guess is there is a short in your starter, draining your
    battery,replace the starter, and your problems should be over. I've seen
    this happen many times.From your discription I believe the starter is the
    problem,but the alternator test is quick and simple, so check that first.
    Good Luck
     
    BobbyG, Jun 28, 2005
    #19
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.