How recalls really should be done

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by George Orwell, Feb 12, 2010.

  1. George Orwell

    hls Guest

    I like to think I had
    I hope so. People need to be pro-active.
    I got a bank employee put in prison once following a similar scenario. He
    deserved it.
     
    hls, Feb 13, 2010
    #21
  2. George Orwell

    Ed Pawlowski Guest

    The GM problem was intake manifolds. They don't leak any fumes. They may
    be a safety device because they suck in poisonous or explosive fumes. They
    saved my life!
     
    Ed Pawlowski, Feb 13, 2010
    #22
  3. George Orwell

    Paul Guest

    The government will save us all.
    One government to protect us,
    one government to control us.
    Long live the government.
    We will live forever.
     
    Paul, Feb 13, 2010
    #23
  4. George Orwell

    hls Guest

    I saw some jackboot senator on the TV this morning discussing the formation
    of
    a consumer protection function of the government. He was against it...He
    said it
    would be populated by academics who would be more in favor of consumer
    protection issues re the customer than people who know about sales and
    profit.

    Turns my stomach.
     
    hls, Feb 13, 2010
    #24
  5. George Orwell

    Dick Cheney Guest

    You mean laden, I think.

    And PBO is a mulatto, not a mongrel. A mongrel is of unknown ancestory.
    We know PBO to be the product of an American tart and a Kenyan buck.

    Dick Cheney excuses your poor command of the english language
    and blames it on public schooling.



    --- news://freenews.netfront.net/ - complaints: ---
     
    Dick Cheney, Feb 13, 2010
    #25
  6. George Orwell

    clare Guest

    The leaky intakes usually leak oil and/or antifreeze onto the engine.
    Hot oil makes smoke/fumes and CAN cause fires. Antifreeze leaks can
    "fume" the windsheild -
    Neither is a COMMON result, but tboth are POSSIBLE.
    Just like a stuck wide open throttle is not a COMMON occurrence on a
    Toyota - but it is POSSIBLE
     
    clare, Feb 13, 2010
    #26
  7. George Orwell

    Canuck57 Guest

    Trouble is now tha tthe NHTSA and Governmetn motors have the same boss,
    really can't say it is impartial any more.
     
    Canuck57, Feb 13, 2010
    #27
  8. George Orwell

    Tom Guest

    Do you know that as a fact or it just another of your WAGs
     
    Tom, Feb 13, 2010
    #28
  9. George Orwell

    Canuck57 Guest

    Are you stupid? Don't answe, it is obvious. But just in case there is
    hope.

    GM, Governemtn Motors is majority owned by the taxpayers. Government
    run, governmetn chooses the board. Government, the same government
    chooses who runs NHTSA and chooses it's management and director.

    Now to say that impartiality is guaranteed, is stupid. To say Toyota
    with 1/3rd the number of defects compared to Government Motors all of a
    sudden changes in one year des sort of stinks of bias and McCarthyism.
     
    Canuck57, Feb 13, 2010
    #29
  10. George Orwell

    Jim Warman Guest

    I commend your efforts... Alberta Infrastructure (the government department
    administering the Out of Province vehicle inspection program - along with
    some other inspections) has been busy making it more difficult for
    charlatans to enjoy the profits found in sidestepping the legislation. In
    the last 5 years, our shop has been inspected three times. Each time, our
    list of required equipment has grown.. and we have met these requirements at
    every turn...

    I must mention, at this point, that we "import" many vehicles for resale. We
    maintain our inspection station permits for this reason... extending the
    inspections to customer vehicles helps to ameliorate some of the costs... Be
    it an "in house" inspection or a retail inspection, an infraction would
    affect my reputation and earning power. I'm a stickler... if you don't like
    my decision, I will show you why my decision is what it is...

    So... let's consider your brake pads... I have no idea of year, make or
    model... no idea of option load... Brake pad taper... if there is a spec in
    the factory manual for brake pad lining taper, this must be considered when
    choosing pass or fail... thickness variation from pad to pad - again, if
    there is a spec in the factory manual....

    If I fail any component on your vehicle, I can show you why it fails and I
    can show you the documentation that confirms the ruling. At this point, it
    becomes obvious that I am supposed to apply MY SIGNATURE to a certificate
    vouching that your car is absolutely safe. At this point, we are
    presupposing that you aren't about to run into someone, you wont cal 1-800-
    SAM and have some sharp as a tack ambulance chaser tear my inspection to
    shreds.... hanging me out to dry on a minor technicality like brake pad
    taper or a missing pedal pad or the e-brake doesn't quite cut it or some
    other seemingly unimportant faux pas...

    The privilege of performing these inspections isn't a licence to print
    money... but the "why" is there in black and white (in the criteria outlined
    in the inspection manual).... and I am not about to jeopardize my career to
    save someone a few bucks.
     
    Jim Warman, Feb 13, 2010
    #30
  11. George Orwell

    Rob Guest


    actually TSBs tell a technician "if a customer comes in compalining of this,
    the problem is possibly this... and heres how to check for that"

    very seldom do you get a free fix. it just helps the tech get to the bottom
    of the problem faster.
     
    Rob, Feb 13, 2010
    #31
  12. George Orwell

    Bill Putney Guest

    The truth is in the middle, at least for 90+% of the TSB's on the 2
    Chrysler Concordes I own - with *very* few exceptions, the last couple
    of lines of any given TSB are:

    "POLICY:
    Reimbursable within the provisions of the warranty."

    meaning if the car is still under warranty, it's fixed under warranty;
    if not still under warranty, then it would be done on my nickel if I
    choose to have it done.
     
    Bill Putney, Feb 14, 2010
    #32
  13. George Orwell

    Bill Putney Guest

    Thank you.
    It was simpler than that. (BTW - 1986 Subaru GL10 turbo station wagon.)
    It was a simple matter of minimum thickness according to the state
    inspection manual. I forget the lower limit, but they were *way* above
    it, and *very* consistent (no taper).

    The brakes on that car were amazing: I sold it with 275k miles (original
    engine, original turbo unit) on it with the original rotors - never had
    them turned, and they were as smooth as a baby's skin the day I sold it.
    Brakes always wore very evenly. Even Subaru has problems with brakes
    today, I guess due to every manufacturer putting weight at a very high
    premium and cutting back on the material/mass. But that's progress, eh? :)
     
    Bill Putney, Feb 14, 2010
    #33
  14. George Orwell

    Rob Guest

    Reimbursable within the provisions of the warranty."

    you are correct sir, i just figured that was obvious
     
    Rob, Feb 14, 2010
    #34
  15. George Orwell

    Clive Guest

    I would guess that it's like fuel injection equipment, just four would
    wide with cross licence. They used to be Lucas here in England, Bosch
    in Germany, Nippon Denso in Japan and AC Delco in America. That was 20
    years ago but I would assume the same sort of system operates today.
     
    Clive, Feb 14, 2010
    #35
  16. George Orwell

    Bill Putney Guest

    Only to people who have seen the TSB's. :) I figured it was worth
    saying it explicitly for that reason.

    --
    Bill Putney
    (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my
    address with the letter 'x')

     
    Bill Putney, Feb 14, 2010
    #36
  17. George Orwell

    Picasso Guest

    TSB's aren't free fixes... they note known problems, and are often only
    available to technicians, and give them a "check this first" if you
    experience "this problem"...

    recalls are free fixes... but how free is it when you have to burn 2-3
    hours toting your vehicle back to the dealer for repair... nothing
    convenient about that. They should come to my house and repair it for
    me in my driveway...
     
    Picasso, Feb 14, 2010
    #37
  18. George Orwell

    Rob Guest

    ok they should string some 220V wires to your switch box to run the
    compressor and dig up your yard to install a lift too! LOL
     
    Rob, Feb 14, 2010
    #38
  19. George Orwell

    Picasso Guest

    Man, good idea. You think they'd do all that just for buying a ford ;)
     
    Picasso, Feb 14, 2010
    #39
  20. George Orwell

    Rob Guest

    maybe a Ferrari FXX



    i hear they ask you to leave it with them when you buy it, and they will let
    you come drive it on THEIR track in Italy. Then they put it back in their
    garage for you again.
     
    Rob, Feb 15, 2010
    #40
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.