Haynes manual instructions

Discussion in 'General Motoring' started by Daniel J. Stern, Nov 10, 2004.

  1. Daniel J. Stern, Nov 10, 2004
    #1
  2. Daniel J. Stern

    Chuck Bremer Guest

    too true!
     
    Chuck Bremer, Nov 10, 2004
    #2
  3. Alex Rodriguez, Nov 10, 2004
    #3
  4. Daniel J. Stern

    Bill 2 Guest

    Actually yes they are. They are filled with so much incorrect, incomplete
    information that your money is better spent paying a couple bucks more for
    the factory service manual.
     
    Bill 2, Nov 10, 2004
    #4
  5. Daniel J. Stern

    Brent P Guest

    I'd rather not have a manual than a haynes or a chiltons...
     
    Brent P, Nov 10, 2004
    #5
  6. The perfect Holiday gift for someone special! ;->
     
    Kenneth P. Stox, Nov 11, 2004
    #6
  7. Daniel J. Stern

    TeGGer® Guest


    Unless you can find that factory service manual on eBay, it will cost quite
    a bit more than a "couple of bucks".

    Haynes for our '91 Integra, $20. Factory service manual, new, $200.

    Haynes for our '99 Tercel, $20. Factory, new, $400.

    I bit the bullet and bought the factory ones. The Honda manual is
    fabulously written and, so far, extremely precise. Well worth every penny
    paid for it.

    The Toyota one is riddled with errors and omissions, almost as bad as the
    Haynes. Very disappointing. When I need something important, I must get the
    correct information from http://techinfo.toyota.com, and they charge for
    it.
     
    TeGGer®, Nov 11, 2004
    #7
  8. Daniel J. Stern

    TeGGer® Guest

    "TeGGer®" <> sprach im


    And by the way, I've got a nearly complete set of factory 1970 Ford Car
    Shop Manuals acquired new when my Dad bought his '70 Custom 500. The only
    one missing is "Volume 4, Body".

    Anybody got Volume 4 for sale? eBay has only one "complete set".
     
    TeGGer®, Nov 11, 2004
    #8
  9. Only if you're stupid enough to think Ebay is the only place to find used
    manuals.
     
    Daniel J. Stern, Nov 11, 2004
    #9
  10. A *couple* of bucks?

    Obviously you have not priced any factory service manuals lately...
     
    Scott en Aztlán, Nov 11, 2004
    #10
  11. Daniel J. Stern

    rex Guest

    ||>
    ||> ||>> In article <>,
    ||>> [email protected] says...
    ||>>
    ||>> >This should be included with every Haynes manual sold:
    ||>> >http://u225.torque.net/haynes_instructions.html
    ||>>
    ||>> While they are not the best choice, they are not quite that bad.
    ||>> ----------------
    ||>> Alex
    ||>
    ||> Actually yes they are. They are filled with so much incorrect, incomplete
    ||> information that your money is better spent paying a couple bucks more for
    ||> the factory service manual.
    ||
    ||I'd rather not have a manual than a haynes or a chiltons...

    You may get your wish. Many of the manufacturers no longer offer a manual to the
    owner. If they do, it may be a CD for $100 or more

    Haynes fills a need for reasonably-priced repair information specific to your
    car. It is correct far more than it is wrong. I have a number of Haynes
    manuals and have yet to find a procedure incorrectly documented. It is true
    that sometimes there is not enough info to answer the questions that come up,
    but for the money I'll accept that.

    I obtain a Haynes manual for every vehicle I acquire. If I can also get a FSM, I
    will, but that's a backup. The Haynes gets the grease smudges.
    Texas Parts Guy
     
    rex, Nov 11, 2004
    #11
  12. I bought the one for my 99 Mazda for $50, but I understand
    undiscounted retail is $100. $400 for Toyota I can believe, too.
     
    Matthew Russotto, Nov 11, 2004
    #12
  13. Daniel J. Stern

    TeGGer® Guest

    (Matthew Russotto) sprach im


    Does that $50 one contain all the EWDs?

    Toyota's $400 is Canadian dollars (about $330 US) and covers both books.
     
    TeGGer®, Nov 11, 2004
    #13
  14. I assume EWDs = wiring diagrams? Yes, it has them, though reduced in
    size. I believe there's a larger version of the manual that
    the dealers have, I don't know how much that one costs.
     
    Matthew Russotto, Nov 11, 2004
    #14
  15. Daniel J. Stern

    E.R. Guest

    In a previous posting, "Bill 2" <> had the audacity
    to say:

    :Actually yes they are. They are filled with so much incorrect, incomplete
    :information that your money is better spent paying a couple bucks more for
    :the factory service manual.

    I was actually dumb enough to buy a Haynes manual once, so I
    actually agree with you and Dan, except for the fact that it's
    not a "couple" of bucks more for the factory service manual.
    It's more like $100 more.
     
    E.R., Nov 11, 2004
    #15
  16. FWIW, Nissan (/Infiniti) has a service where you pay $20 and get 24
    hours of access to their entire techpubs library. You then download
    all the .PDFs you're interested in, and save 'em to CD-ROM. I got
    my FX' service manual this way, ~40-odd .PDFs spread out over ~200MB.

    I even printed all gazillion pages in 4-up, duplex (i.e., 8 pages/
    sheet) mode- while you can't really do any work in that format (when
    I needed to check on something, I just printed the appropriate pages
    normally), it's good as a guide as to where to look.

    But if you buy the CD, it's $200.

    -Kenny
     
    Kenneth Crudup, Nov 11, 2004
    #16
  17. Daniel J. Stern

    Ted Johnson Guest

    This should be included with every Haynes manual sold:
    There's a huge variation, depending on which model car the Haynes
    manual is for. Different authors, I guess.

    For example, the '87 tercel manual is excellent.
    But the 3-series BMW manual is crap.

    -Ted
     
    Ted Johnson, Nov 11, 2004
    #17
  18. The Haynes manual for my 1997 Nissan left out the torque specs for my
    brakes and front suspension, and they kept referring to a "torque
    member" but never explained what it was. It said that the fuel filter
    was in the rear, but it was actually in the engine compartment (and it
    wasn't a matter of the car having two fuel filters). The body
    information was for a different model (one illustration was for an
    early 1970s vehicle and even said "Datsun"), and the wiring diagram
    was labelled "typical," which is a euphemism for "completely different
    from your car." And when it came to information about the computer
    codes and fuel/emissions, the Haynes excluded almost everything, and
    the diagnostic charts for drivability problems seemed to be 100%
    generic. For example for rough idle they gave the usual hints, like
    spark, lean mixture, and wrong idle speed, but they mentioned nothing
    at all about the idle speed regulator.
     
    larrymoencurly, Nov 11, 2004
    #18
  19. Daniel J. Stern

    Bill 2 Guest

    Factor in the money you didn't waste buying wrong parts, or damaging parts
    following Haynes instructions, lost time following wrong procedures,
    repairing the hole in the wall from when you were so pissed off at the book
    you punched a hole in it, etc.

    Not typical, but I just did a quick check on Ebay for the FSM for my car and
    it was $5 "Buy it now" + $5 shipping. The Haynes manual bidding started at
    $15.

    New I probably bought the manual for $100-$150, and I can see when the FSM
    is $400 people look at other options, but I still think Haynes and Chilton's
    are poor options.
    And worth every penny.
     
    Bill 2, Nov 12, 2004
    #19
  20. Daniel J. Stern

    Bill Putney Guest

    Except, after I had learned my lesson years earlier on aftermarket
    manuals, a few months after I bought my daughter a used car, the very
    first opportunity that came up for diagnosis and repair of an electrical
    problem, in a weak moment, I went down the street and sprung for a whole
    $13 for a Haynes manual. Due to a visibly hidden fuse that was not
    shown in the "TYPICAL" schematics of the Haynes, I ended up replacing a
    perfectly good factory alternator when all that was wrong was that the
    in-line fuse that the manual did not show had mechanically fractured.
    Aftermarket alt. cost $260, plus I now had an inferior aftermarket alt.
    in place of the factory one. FSM would have cost around $90. Tell me:
    Did I save any money? You do the math (13 + 260 vs. 90 + 5).

    BTW, I found out after the fact that, without exception, every vehicle
    of the span of years and model variation covered by that Haynes manual
    came from the factory with that fuse, and, after purchasing the FSM the
    next day, verified that that fuse was clearly shown in the schematics,
    yet the Haynes schematic was labeled "TYPICAL".

    Bill Putney
    (To reply by e-mail, replace the last letter of the alphabet in my
    adddress with the letter 'x')
     
    Bill Putney, Nov 12, 2004
    #20
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.